Best Local Pies for Thanksgiving in Austin

Tiny Pies
5035 Burnet Rd, Ste. 100, Austin, TX 78756
Tiny Pies puts a fun twist on traditional holiday desserts with its signature personal-sized pies and larger options made for sharing. The bakery is known for its variety of sweet flavors, including apple crumb, Sweet Texas pecan, chocolate cream, coconut cream, and seasonal specialties. It also offers savory options, including individual pot pies, making it a good stop for both dessert and a little something extra for the holiday table.
If you're planning ahead, consider placing an order for Thanksgiving pickup before the holiday rush. Preorders typically close around November 20, so it's a good idea to check the current menu and reserve your favorites early.
Quack’s 43rd Street Bakery
411 E 43rd Street, Austin, Texas 78751`
A longtime Austin favorite, Quack's 43rd Street Bakery is a great choice for anyone who prefers traditional Thanksgiving desserts. Its holiday pie selection includes familiar favorites such as pumpkin, pecan, apple cinnamon, and chocolate cream, along with options like cherry and peach cranberry crumble. You can also find other seasonal sweets, cakes, and pastries if you're looking to add a little variety to your dessert spread.
The bakery typically accepts preorders with pickup options during Thanksgiving week. It's a convenient stop for anyone who wants a homemade-style dessert without spending the day in the kitchen.
Bakery Lorraine
11600 Rock Rose Ave #100, Austin, TX 78758
For a Thanksgiving dessert with a little French-inspired flair, Bakery Lorraine is worth a visit. Known for its beautiful pastries, tarts, macarons, and specialty desserts, the bakery also offers an impressive selection of holiday pies. Its seasonal lineup includes roasted pumpkin streusel, whiskey pecan, Dutch apple, sweet potato meringue, and chocolate cream, giving guests a few more interesting choices beyond the usual holiday favorites.
Planning ahead is especially helpful during the holiday season, as Thanksgiving preorders typically close between mid and late November. Check the bakery's current selection and pickup schedule to make sure your favorite makes it to the table.

Sugar Mama’s Bakeshop
1905 South 1st Street, Austin, TX, 78704
Sugar Mama's Bakeshop is a South Austin favorite known for its cupcakes, custom cakes, and creative baked treats. Its Thanksgiving selection gives traditional desserts a little extra personality, with flavors such as chocolate bourbon pecan, pumpkin, Dutch apple, and chocolate cream. The bakery also offers specialty treats throughout the year, making it a good place to check if you're looking for something beyond a standard holiday pie.
Whether you're bringing dessert to a family gathering or handling the entire holiday menu, these pies are worth checking out. Be sure to visit the bakery's website for its latest Thanksgiving selections and preorder deadlines.
Upper Crust Bakery
4508 Burnet Rd, Austin, TX
A familiar name in Austin's baking scene, Upper Crust Bakery has been serving the community for more than 40 years. Its pies are made from scratch and are known for their generous, extra-deep-dish size, making them a good option for larger Thanksgiving gatherings. Popular choices include pecan, Dutch apple, and seasonal pumpkin, with additional flavors available throughout the year.
The bakery generally begins accepting holiday orders in early November, with preorders closing around mid-month. If you have a particular pie in mind, ordering early is a smart way to make sure it doesn't get away before Thanksgiving.
Rockman Coffee + Bakeshop
2400 East Cesar Chavez Street, Austin, TX, 78702
Rockman Coffee + Bakeshop brings together specialty coffee and creative pastries, making it a fun stop for anyone with a sweet tooth. Led by pastry chef Amanda Rockman, the East Austin bakery is known for its thoughtfully prepared baked goods, including croissants, cookies, cinnamon rolls, and seasonal desserts. Its Thanksgiving offerings are especially interesting for guests who enjoy trying something a little different from the traditional holiday lineup.
Thanksgiving preorders typically wrap up between November 19 and 23, with pickup scheduled during the week of the holiday. Check its current offerings early so you have time to pick out something special for dessert.

Gati
1512 Holly St. Austin, TX 78702
For guests with dietary restrictions, Gati is a bakery worth adding to your Thanksgiving list. The East Austin shop specializes in gluten-free baked goods and also offers vegan-friendly desserts, making it a helpful option when you're planning a holiday table for guests with different dietary preferences. Its regular selection includes muffins, brownies, coffee cakes, and other baked treats, along with small-batch vegan ice cream.
You may also find pumpkin rolls among its holiday selections, adding another option to the dessert spread. Preorder deadlines typically fall in mid-to-late November, so check its website or Instagram for the latest 2026 menu and ordering details.
Abby Jane Bakeshop
16604 Fitzhugh Rd, unit C, Dripping Springs, TX 78620
A little trip to Dripping Springs could lead you to your next Thanksgiving dessert favorite. Abby Jane Bakeshop is a Hill Country bakery known for its artisan breads, pastries, and carefully crafted baked goods. Its holiday selection brings together familiar Thanksgiving flavors and more creative combinations, including apple crumble, maple pecan, pumpkin cheesecake, and chocolate maple pecan pies. The bakery also offers seasonal treats beyond pies, making it a good option if you're putting together a larger assortment for your holiday gathering.
The selection gives traditional holiday flavors a little extra personality, making this bakery worth adding to your Thanksgiving shopping list. Preorders typically close around November 20, so be sure to check the current menu and arrange your pickup ahead of time.
Tootie Pie Co.
3992 E HWY 290, Dripping Springs, TX 78620
Tootie Pie Co. brings a classic, generously sized pie to the Thanksgiving table. The company specializes in handcrafted pies made with all-natural ingredients and offers a broad selection of traditional and specialty flavors. From pumpkin and pecan to apple, whiskey pecan, and cream pies, its assortment makes it easy to find something for different dessert preferences.
The bakery offers both retail and wholesale options, making it a choice for individual holiday gatherings or larger celebrations. Take a look at its current selection to find the right pie for your Thanksgiving spread.
Papi's Pies
10 Chisholm Trail Rd, Suite B, Round Rock, TX 78681
Papi's Pies is a family-owned bakery and café in Round Rock with a menu inspired by family recipes, local favorites, and European classics. Along with its handmade pies, the shop prepares fresh pastries, savory quiches, and other baked goods in-house. Its welcoming atmosphere and focus on homemade food make it a nice local option for anyone looking to support a Central Texas business while preparing for Thanksgiving.
Its current Thanksgiving flavors and preorder schedule should be confirmed directly with the shop, but it's worth keeping on your list if you're looking to support a local Central Texas bakery. Sometimes, the best holiday finds are right around the corner!

A Little Thanksgiving Reminder
The best pies tend to disappear quickly around Thanksgiving, so don't wait until the last minute to place your order. Check each bakery's current menu, prices, and pickup dates ahead of time. And if your plans come together a little later than expected, Central Market and Whole Foods are good backup options for picking up dessert. 🥧
Recent Posts









